By Alex Knapp | November 20, 2026
Last Updated on November 20, 2026
Alex Knapp, founder of 1two.one, sets out to make supervision in adult social care more valuable – for managers and care workers.
Care Quality Commission (CQC) Regulation 18 requires providers to make sure staff receive appropriate supervision and appraisal, and similarly in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland. Yet, it is one of the first things to slip when we are busy.
So, if supervision has to happen, and time is the one thing every manager is short of, are we getting full value from the hours spent on it? The following research says we are not and this is the result of how we run supervision: as multiple jobs all at once.
For the multi-taskers
Take a typical supervision: asking questions, listening to the answers, deciding what to ask next and recording. Four jobs – simultaneously. Psychologists have studied multi-tasking and the findings are consistent.
In 1994, Harold Pashler described the ‘central bottleneck’. We can take in several things at once, but the brain cannot make decisions or select responses for two tasks at the same time. When two tasks compete for that capacity, one is put on hold while the other completes.
In 2001, Rubinstein, Meyer and Evans examined what happens when we switch between tasks. Each switch requires the brain to change its goal, set aside the rules for one task and pick up the rules for the other. Done repeatedly, those switches cost time and increase errors.
In 2006, a team at Vanderbilt University used brain imaging to show the same limit in action. The part of the brain responsible for executive control could not process two operations at once. Activity for the second task waited until the first was finished.
Listening and note-taking are exactly this kind of competing pair. A manager doing both is doing each at half capacity. They are switching between them, and every switch costs something. You might think you are a great multi-tasker, your brain thinks otherwise.
Lost in the switch
The note-taker misses the moment. The pause before someone answers a difficult question. The change in tone when something uncomfortable comes up. The remark made in passing could be the most important thing said all session. The listener loses the record. Memory is selective and fades fast. Written up afterwards, the notes reflect what the manager remembered, not necessarily what was said.
Jamie Stewart, Social Care Transformation Manager at Suffolk County Council, described this more precisely than any study could: ‘When I was taking notes, I didn’t always feel that I was present in the conversation because I was desperately trying to capture what was being discussed and then think about what needed to be done next.’
Wider supervision evidence
Cognitive science explains why divided attention weakens supervision. A 2021 review in BMJ Open of 135 studies of clinical supervision across healthcare, shows what is at stake. Effective supervision is consistently linked to staff retention, job satisfaction, wellbeing and an increase in care quality. Staff who had sessions of an hour or more saw their supervision as more effective. Where people lacked a shared understanding of supervision, some experienced it as surveillance rather than support.
The review draws on doctors, nurses, psychologists and allied health professionals rather than adult social care. The findings are relevant: the quality of the hour matters, not just the fact that it happened.
Time
Managers are time poor so anything that saves time while improving the quality of supervision should be welcomed. The current approach does neither. Supervision spent part-listening and part-writing and more time afterwards ‘typing up’ means the organisation pays for the session twice and gets a weaker version of both the conversation and the record.
Documentation matters. CQC inspections are looking for the evidence of not just that supervision happened, but what was discussed, the agreed actions and what was the impact of the agreed actions. The issue is that documentation has come at the expense of the conversation, rather than as a record of it.
Active listening
Now take the recording role away. Let technology capture and structure the record and enable the manager to just actively listen. What happens when your full attention is on the supervisee?
- Competence, in the worker’s own words: A care worker explaining how they supported someone tells you far more about their practice than a certificate. When the full conversation is captured, that explanation becomes evidence, mapped against the Care Certificate and the CQC regulations.
- Early warning signs: People rarely announce they are thinking of leaving; they hint at it. A manager who is listening rather than writing is more likely to notice while there is time to act.
- Wellbeing and restorative supervision: The space to sit with a silence after a difficult disclosure, rather than filling it with note taking. That quality of presence means people feel supported, and it shows in staff retention.
- Learning needs that surface naturally: Gaps in confidence or knowledge often emerge sideways in conversation. Captured accurately, they feed straight into training plans.
- Better questions: The most useful questions in supervision are rarely the planned ones. They come from noticing something and following the thread. That only happens when attention is not divided.
- A record both people can trust: What was actually said, not what one person remembered. That protects the worker and the manager equally and goes a long way to addressing the fear that supervision will be ‘used against me’.
- A year of evidence, not a scramble: When every session is recorded accurately, the annual appraisal becomes a synthesis of what is already there.
Restoring, not replacing
When note-taking disappears, the connection in the conversation is restored. Supervision is not optional. The only real choice is whether managers spend that time doing multiple jobs at half capacity, or one job properly. When the record becomes a by-product of the conversation rather than a tax on it, managers get time back and their teams get a better version of supervision.
Alex Knapp is the founder of 1two.one and previously founded Grey Matter Learning in 2006.
- Pashler, H. (1994). Dual-task interference in simple tasks: Data and theory. Psychological Bulletin, 116, 220–244.
- Rubinstein, J.S., Meyer, D.E., & Evans, J.E. (2001). Executive control of cognitive processes in task switching. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 27(4), 763–797.
- Dux, P.E., Ivanoff, J., Asplund, C.L., & Marois, R. (2006). Isolation of a central bottleneck of information processing with time-resolved fMRI. Neuron, 52, 1109–1120.
- Rothwell, C., Kehoe, A., Farook, S.F., & Illing, J. (2021). Enablers and barriers to effective clinical supervision in the workplace: a rapid evidence review. BMJ Open, 11(9), e052929.
- Jamie Stewart quote: System C, ‘Purposeful Innovation with AI in Health and Social Care’, systemc.com.