post image

Building public support: #socialcarefuture

#socialcarefuture is a growing movement. Co-convener of #socialcarefuture Neil Crowther shares findings and recommendations of new research into how to build public support to transform social care.

We have all endured restrictions and loss over the past year, reminding us of the value we place upon being in control of our lives, doing things that matter to us and being with the people we care about. The horizon of our lives and the choices we have been able to make have been extremely limited by events beyond our control.

 Changing the social care story

The restrictions imposed upon those of us living in care homes have kept loved ones apart for months, some never to spend time with one another ever again. Given the evidence of the risks faced by those living in congregate care, we might see such measures as necessary. And yet, isolated and absent from the routines, interests, places and familiar people from which all of us draw meaning and purpose, the wellbeing of many people who are literally imprisoned in such settings has been seriously harmed. Even if they were fortunate not to get COVID, COVID still got them. Meanwhile, members of the #socialcaremovement who draw on social care to live in their own homes have commented that the support they received prior to the pandemic was already often so threadbare and restrictive that the lockdowns have not felt all that different from their everyday existence.

Without a significant shift, the future currently being anticipated for people who have reason to draw on social care is akin to a permanent lockdown and all the damage that will cause. With all this in mind, one would hope that we would never now regard ‘a good approach’ to social care as one that simply aims to keep people alive. ‘And yet, that is still how social care is overwhelmingly talked and thought about in general by the public, the media and political think tanks: as washing, feeding and dressing ‘vulnerable people who cannot look after themselves.’ Even when we read, listen or talk about ‘fixing social care’, all that is usually meant is funding more of the same old institutional or ‘life and limb’ care.

This is the dead hand of an unsupportive narrative in action. The public story of social care is an obstruction to building the future that all of us really wants for each other. That’s why #socialcarefuture set out to understand how it could be changed and we’re extremely pleased to be able to report that it can.

Shifting mindsets

Following exposure to a new narrative, developed in partnership with strategic communications experts Equally Ours and public opinion researchers Survation, a survey of over 3,000 people found that they:

  • Regarded social care as important to themselves and to those close to them (rising from 44% pre-exposure to 55% after).
  • Regarded social care as a benefit to both those who need support and the wider community (rising from 58% pre-exposure to 68% after). Placed greater priority to social care above other areas of Government policy.
  • Supported more investment in social care from central Government (rising from 60% pre-exposure to 67% after).
  • Believed that it’s possible to start organising social care in a better and more sustainable way now (rising from 52% pre-exposure to 63% after).

#socialcarefuture quote

Crucially, the route to achieving these results was to shift mindsets from the limited and limiting thinking about social care outlined above towards one rooted in people being empowered to lead the lives they want to lead through the support and relationships they enjoy in their local community. Following exposure to our new narrative, people were:

  • Significantly less likely to associate social care with paternalistic ideas such as vulnerability and compassion (declining from 50% to 27% and from 52% to 36%, respectively).
  • Far more likely to associate it with words such as independence, community and relationships (increasing from 19% to 33%, 12% to 31% and 12% to 31%, respectively).

They were also more likely to agree with the statements that:

  • ‘Social care is about people having the support to live how, where and with whom they choose to’ (increasing from 61% pre-exposure to 70% post).
  • ‘Social care draws together relationships and support’ (from 51% pre-exposure to 65% post).
  • ‘Living how we choose to live is dependent on the strength of the relationships that we have’ (49% pre-exposure to 60% post).

New narrative

What is the new narrative that achieved these results? Some of it may already be familiar because #socialcarefuture has been promoting it for almost two years:

‘We all want to live in the place we call home, with the people and things that we love, in communities where we look out for one another, doing what matters to us.’

we all want to live in a place we call home. Socialcarefuture quote

This opening, values-led, hopeful statement establishes in our audience’s mind the life that social care should help us all to lead. It invokes values of self-direction, solidarity and belonging. It addresses everyone. Moreover, as the communications expert Anat Shenker-Osorio reminds us, ‘People buy the brownie, not the recipe’ – it focuses on people leading good lives, not on the plight of a ‘system’ or ‘sector.’

We then briefly explain why we might need social care, linking it back to the headline vision:

‘If we or someone we care about has a disability or health condition during their life, we might need some support to do these things. That’s the role of social care.’

Again, while linking social care to health and disability, we avoid presenting it as pertaining to ‘others’ or fixed groups, using the word ‘we’ throughout and leaving open the possibility that it is something we may all have reason to call upon.

We then set out how we believe social care should work when working well:

‘When organised well, social care helps to weave the web of relationships and support in our local communities that we can draw on to live our lives in the way that we want to, whatever our age or stage of life.’

web of support #socialcarefuture quote

Here, we introduce the idea of social care not as a single transactional service delivered to people or as a place people go to, but as the drawing together of formal and informal support and relationships on which people can draw to live the lives they wish to. ‘Weaving the web’ is one of a number of metaphors we successfully tested to create a mental shortcut to this idea, along with social care as ‘the glue that binds’ and social care helping to ‘nurture an ecosystem’ of relationships and support. We employed real-life examples to bring these ideas to life, focusing on personal assistance, wellbeing teams, community circles and local area co-ordination.

Having defined what good social care is, the final stage of our narrative sets out what needs to happen to bring this to everyone:

‘We believe that this can and should be happening everywhere and for everyone. For that to happen, the Government must make good social care a priority and begin investing more in it. And more local councils need urgently to start working alongside and supporting local people and organisations to bring these ideas to life by organising and funding social care differently now.’

government must make social care a priority #socialcarefuture quote

The potential is powerful

During the research, some participants rightly noted that as much as they liked our vision and approach, it was not something that could be realised immediately. That needn’t, however, mean that we cannot make a start on building it, hence we talk about Government making it a priority and beginning to invest more and local authorities needing to urgently start working differently now. There was also some concern expressed during the earlier stages of our research that approaches which involved enlisting support from the community could mean Government absenting itself, hence we implicate central Government, local Government and local people and organisations. Finally, we characterise the nature of the relationship that we believe should exist between local councils and communities by using the phrase ‘working alongside and supporting local people and organisations’.

Of course, the results we are able to share here took place within the simulated conditions of audience research. Various factors will mediate how effective this narrative is in the wider world, including its messengers, how creatively it is delivered, the degree to which it comes to be adopted by social care’s advocates, the moments that create opportunities to deploy it, whether the media adopts it and our ability to deliver it at scale to target audiences.

However, what our research clearly demonstrates is the potential to command stronger support for investment and reform of social care and that the positive vision and approach developed by #socialcarefuture offers a persuasive and powerful way to do so.


The research and guidance on how to put the narrative into action will be available later in April at:
www.socialcarefuture.blog

Neil Crowther is a co-convener of the #socialcarefuture movement. Twitter: @socialcarefuture. Email: crowtherconsulting@gmail.com

 

 

 

 

 

Neil Crowther

About Neil Crowther

Neil Crowther is a co-convener of the #socialcarefuture movement. He is also an independent researcher and social change consultant. Neil’s father, who died last September, had Alzheimer’s disease and through this Neil has experience of trying to navigate the current social care ‘system’. His parents were fortunate to benefit from the creation of a ‘community circle’ to support them, an idea that is part of #socialcarefuture’s vision for the future.

Related Content

Into Perspective

Straight Talk

What if…? A different social care

Can the social care sector change public perceptions?

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Support care workers in need during COVID-19. Donate to the Care Workers' Charity Emergency Fund. Donate