post image

Into perspective: What can the sector learn from the UK Covid-19 Inquiry?

Kate Eisenstein, Deputy Secretary of the UK Covid-19 Inquiry, emphasises that the ‘unrecognised and unprotected’ adult social care sector cannot be forgotten in the next pandemic.

More than 43,000 people in care homes died from or with Covid-19 during the pandemic. Providers were asked to make unenviable choices in the face of a potentially deadly virus. Many were faced with the dual challenge of protecting people who use their services, while also supporting them to live fulfilling, connected lives.

One registered manager I met in Coventry as part of the Inquiry’s listening exercise, Every Story Matters, described tearfully how she had tried to do both, all while worrying about her own safety and that of her family.

Her story is just one of 47,000 stories the Inquiry heard as part of its investigation into the adult social care sector. These stories were considered carefully alongside more than 100,000 pages of written evidence and 57 witnesses who gave evidence.

Inquiry Chair, Baroness Heather Hallett, heard how failings in Government planning and response created environments in which the virus could spread like wildfire.

The adult social care sector had been neglected in past pandemic planning, with confusion between the planning responsibilities of providers, local authorities, local resilience forums and Government. The pandemic exposed and exacerbated the underlying fragility of the social care workforce.

Government claims that a ‘protective ring’ had been thrown around care homes from the start was simply not true. Baroness Hallett concluded that the whole sector appeared to be something of an afterthought. As one domiciliary care worker told us, ‘the NHS were not the only heroes’.

The Inquiry heard about the difficulties that staff and providers experienced when trying to limit the spread of Covid-19. Some care home staff told us they felt obliged to take untested patients discharged from hospital despite the risk to their own communities and staff shortages.

In some domiciliary care providers, as many as 25% of staff were self-isolating at any one time and 80% reported shortages of PPE. Efforts to limit movement of care workers between different locations presented significant challenges.

We heard heartbreaking accounts of the impact of visiting restrictions on all those involved. These were introduced to protect people from Covid-19 but often led to other significant harm.

One parent told us they went six months without being able to see their adult son who has severe autism and lives in residential care. Many visits to care homes could only take place through a window, causing confusion for the resident and distress to resident, visitor and staff alike. Unable to visit their loved ones for months at a time, families have been left grief and guilt stricken, asking themselves if they could have done more.

Visiting guidance must be improved. It should be developed in consultation with those who use and work in social care. Measures should be the least restrictive possible and decided at the most local level.

Many care workers showed extraordinary dedication and compassion, often at risk to their own health and lives. Providers and their staff supported seriously unwell people and those with complex care and support needs, often without adequate training or PPE.

The reduced support from healthcare staff, serious staff shortages and visiting restrictions placed greater pressure on care staff, particularly when a resident was dying. The Inquiry has therefore recommended that all health and social care professionals who work in care settings should have training in end of life care.

Changes intended to strengthen the resilience of the workforce and support care workers are also recommended. This includes a voluntary professional workforce register for care staff in England – something that already exists in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland – to help provide a better career pathway, professionalise care work and make it easier to communicate with care workers across the country in the next public health emergency.

There will be another pandemic. We just do not know when. That is why Baroness Hallett has recommended essential changes to the way the sector prepares for next time. It is vital that all of the Chair’s findings are heeded and recommendations implemented.

Users of care, care workers and unpaid carers bore the cost of being an unrecognised and unprotected part of society. This cannot be allowed to happen again.

Kate Eisenstein is Deputy Secretary of the UK Covid-19 Inquiry. Email: [email protected] Linkedin: @UK-Covid-19-Inquiry


Recommendations are not protection
 

Care workers were failed and it ran through the whole system. The consequence, in Baroness Hallett’s words, was ‘the wholly unacceptable position that care workers had to either work in unsuitable or poor-quality PPE, or with no PPE at all, and so without the protection they needed’.

CWC was there throughout, supporting care workers through some of the darkest times society has seen. We launched our Covid-19 Emergency Fund at the end of March 2020, weeks before Government funding for care workers’ sick pay arrived in England and months before it reached Wales.

Between March 2020 and June 2022, we awarded 4,351 grants worth more than £2.6m. More than 3,500 went to care workers who had to self-isolate and could not afford to. From 2021, we funded therapy for more than 300 care workers struggling with what they had lived through. Every one of those grants represents a decision a care worker should never have had to make.

What we want to see learned is that care workers are skilled professionals, and that we can no longer afford to take advantage of their goodwill. Without the protection they were promised, care workers met the moment with skill, compassion and dedication, delivering outstanding care to some of the most vulnerable people. They did it while exposing themselves and the people they love to real risk and without the recognition they deserved.

Three of the Inquiry’s eight recommendations speak directly to the workforce, and we echo
all three:

  • Financial support from day one of a future pandemic: No care worker should ever again have to choose between isolating and paying their rent.
  • Counting the care workers we lost: Nobody centrally recorded how many care workers died of Covid-19. Every one of them deserves to be counted.
  • A workforce register for England: Recognition is long overdue, and the cost must not fall on a low paid workforce. A register should recognise care workers, not charge them for the privilege.

Recommendations, however, are not protection. Module 6 shows a sector unprepared because it had never been prioritised and a workforce that paid for it. We must act now to safeguard against future pandemics.

Karolina Gerlich, Chief Executive Officer, The Care Workers’ Charity (CWC) Email: [email protected] Linkedin: @The-Care-Workers’- Charity


Put adult social care at the heart of crisis planning

As the membership organisation for not-for-profit providers, we know the lengths our members went to keep people safe and as connected as possible to their families and communities, while making sure staff were protected and supported. These stories were featured in our Caring in COVID book, recording the resilience, courage and commitment with which not-for-profit providers met the challenges the pandemic presented.

While much attention rightly focused on care homes, the experiences of working-age adults who rely on social care and support should not be forgotten. For many people with learning disabilities, autistic people, individuals with mental health needs and those living with physical disabilities, the impact of restrictions extended far beyond concerns about the virus itself. Access to family, friends, employment, education, community activities and vital support networks was disrupted, often for prolonged periods.

The Inquiry’s findings reinforce a central lesson: social care cannot be treated as an afterthought and must be prioritised in any future pandemic or national crisis. The work being undertaken by Baroness Casey on a National Care Service will be vital to ensuring that social care is given the political priority it deserves.

The recommendations around workforce support, improved data collection, professional recognition and future pandemic preparedness are important and welcome. However, their significance extends beyond the workforce, and a pandemic situation, alone. A resilient, properly supported social care sector is fundamental to protecting the rights, wellbeing and quality of life of people who draw on care and support services.

The Inquiry makes clear that there will be future public health emergencies. The challenge now is to ensure that the lessons identified are translated into meaningful action as part of the efforts to build a National Care Service. We cannot have a major opportunity for reform which leaves the pre-pandemic vulnerabilities in place.

It is therefore timely and very welcome to hear Baroness Casey be so clear in her views as she spoke at the National Children and Adult Services Conference, only a few weeks after the publication of the Module 6 report, about the need for radical reform in social care, not more tinkering around the edges.

Professor Vic Rayner OBE, Chief Executive Officer, National Care Forum (NCF). Email: [email protected] Linkedin: @National-Care-Forum

 

About Karolina Gerlich

Karolina Gerlich is Chief Executive Officer at The Care Workers’ Charity and has been a care worker for over twelve years. Leading the CWC since March 2020, Karolina has already had a huge impact, i…

Read More

ncreasing the CWC’s efficiency, platform and support giving capacity. She is proud to represent the social care workforce and embodies the mission that no care worker should face hardship alone.

About Kate Eisenstein

Kate Eisenstein is the Deputy Secretary and Director of Policy, Engagement and Legal at the UK Covid-19 Inquiry, where she oversees the delivery of the inquiry’s investigations….

Read More

About Professor Vic Rayner

Professor Vic Rayner OBE is Chief Executive Officer at the National Care Forum (NCF). She chairs Government’s national workforce and national social care advisory groups. Vic is a regular national a…

Read More

nd international speaker and has extensive knowledge and expertise across a wide range of care, support, housing and social policy agendas. Vic is the incoming chair of the Global Ageing Network and h as worked extensively with international partners on key areas of innovation and change.

Related Content

Social Care Insights

Homecare Headlines

The UK Covid-19 Inquiry: Lessons must be learnt

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted