post image

Picking up the pace
Protecting the human rights of people with a learning disability and autistic people 

If a true measure of society is how it treats people in some of the most vulnerable circumstances, then what can be said of Government’s commitment to reduce its reliance on long-stay assessment and treatment provision for autistic people and people with a learning disability? Dr Rhidian Hughes examines the issue in depth. 

Behind schedule 

In the NHS Long Term Plan, the Government made a commitment to reduce the numbers of autistic people and people with a learning disability living in in-patient settings. The commitment made was to reduce the numbers by half by March 2024. However, there are still over 2,000 children and adults in these facilities, meaning the reduction is only around one third.  

In 2015, there were 2,905 autistic people and people with a learning disability in these units. Despite some progress, the speed and scale of transformation has fallen far short of the aspiration and, nearly 10 years on, latest NHS England figures show the number of autistic people in inpatient facilities has actually increased. 

Data from NHS England points to an increase of 7.3% in the numbers of autistic inpatients (both with and without a learning disability) in mental health hospitals between March 2017 and August 2023, and an increase of 51.3% in the number of autistic people without a learning disability in the same timeframe. The reasons for this are many and complex but include a Mental Capacity Act in need of reform, a lack of early support that can help prevent the escalation of need, a more nuanced approach to risk management and minimisation of restrictive practices. Successive targets to reduce the number of people being referred to these settings and increase referrals into the community have been missed.  

Missed opportunities 

Almost a decade ago, NHS England, the Local Government Association (LGA) and the Association of Directors of Adult Social Services (ADASS) published Building the Right Support: guidance supporting commissioners to reduce the number of people with a learning disability and autistic people in a mental health inpatient setting and seeking to develop community alternatives to inpatient care. Since its publication, there has been no shortage of service models, specifications and supplementary guidance published. All of this should have meant fewer people needing to go into hospital for care. 

These are settings that are highly restrictive, secluded and use physical restraints and over-medication, which are seriously flawed and fundamentally wrong care models. Scandals including Winterbourne View, Cawston Park and Whorlton Hall have all brought people’s experiences into sharp focus. Recently, the judge overseeing the case of four carers convicted of abusing people at Whorlton Hall said the setting had a ‘malign culture’ and was an ‘unpredictable and inherently frightening place to live’. 

Priorities for change 

National commissioning guidelines for integrated care boards (ICBs) state that an in-patient stay ‘should be for the minimum time possible, for assessment and/or treatment which can only be provided in hospital’. To meet this guidance requires established procurement routes to be disrupted and a vibrant care and support market commissioned.  

Yet the market for support providers has been largely over-looked nationally. We have seen little evidence that ICBs have plans to help people move out of hospital or crucially avoid being admitted in the first place. We see little upstream investment, while few providers have been encouraged or supported to develop the kinds of community-based services that would provide the alternative to inpatient provision so desperately needed. In some areas we see demand, made up of people ready for discharge, outstripping the supply of high-quality housing and support packages.  

There is an urgent need to build social care provider capability, capacity and – crucially – shared interests and values in supporting people, in what is an area of highly complex work. Done well, good commissioning invests to save over the longer term. It resources prevention, partners with community providers and housing suppliers and draws on the experiences of people with lived experience and their families who articulate readily what they need, namely funding in the right place, well-managed transitions between services and skilled staff. But this practice is far from universal, and the system is not on the right course to evidence significant improvement. 

Previous governments acted on the scandals of long-stay hospitals with legislation and funding. As a general election looms, the new Government must intentionally draw on the levers it has available to make far better progress than we have witnessed in recent years.  

Creating a unified voice 

Working with the Challenging Behaviour Foundation and others, we wrote to all political leaders urging them to protect the human rights of autistic people and people with a learning disability. We need the next administration to create and maintain political will to make these ambitions a reality.  

VoiceAbility is calling on the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care to intervene and use the new power in the Health and Social Care Act 2022 to direct NHS England to urgently reduce the number of people with a learning disability and autistic people in assessment and treatment units. Doing so would strengthen public accountability across the system.  

In addition, we are continuing to call on the Secretary of State to direct the Care Quality Commission (CQC) to rate all assessment and treatment units as ‘Requires improvement’ if anyone has been living there for more than 12 months. In addition, for that rating to be downgraded to ‘Inadequate’ if anyone has been living there for more than 24 months and for all new admissions to be halted until the rating has improved. The Secretary of State should also require the National Audit Office to present an annual report to parliament on progress.  

Time to act 

There are citizens who are detained in NHS-funded accommodation, some for many years, and in some instances for over a decade – this is the responsibility of central Government. It would be hard to imagine any other circumstances in which a British citizen could be detained indefinitely by the state, without a trial. Especially, where Government has explicitly acknowledged that the conditions of their detention are, for the majority, inappropriate and should be ended. Yet, they continue to detain them in precisely the same, and in some instances worse, circumstances over many years.  

There is no shortage of reports containing practical solutions and no further general reviews are required. There is no debate or disagreement that the placement of people in assessment and treatment units for extended periods of time is damaging to their wellbeing. Neither is there a shortage of knowledge and expertise, including from people with lived experience and their families seeking better outcomes. We know what’s needed, but we need a plan and commitment from Government to act with urgency to address this human rights scandal.  

We stand with partners committed to the closure of all inappropriate settings for autistic people and people with a learning disability. We need to push for this to be a national priority and, as the general election looms, we need an administration that is willing to relegate these institutions to the past. 


What are your sector-specific priorities for the next government? Leave a comment on this article or join the conversation to share your thoughts.  

Dr Rhidian Hughes is Chief Executive at the Voluntary Organisations Disability Group (VODG).  

Email: [email protected]  X: @RhidianHughes @VODGmembership 

About Dr Rhidian Hughes

Prior to joining VODG, Rhidian’s career spanned a range of senior research, regulation and consultancy roles. He worked in management consultancy across the health and social care sectors and before that, in regulation. Earlier in his career, Rhidian held academic appointments, leading programmes of social policy research. Rhidian was educated at the University of York where he also earned his Doctorate.

Related Content

Seeking clarity post-Winterbourne View: Has the Transforming Care agenda been fulfilled?

Fork in the road: A timely opportunity for people with mental health conditions, ADHD and autism

Bridging the gap: Local and national older people’s housing

Getting winter ready: The essential guide to reducing seasonal pressures

Straight Talk

Pick and mixed: Making social care sweet for all

Into Perspective: Technology

Playing the long game: How much political progress has been made for social care reform in 2023?

The Care Innovation Challenge: CMM meets the finalists

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted