Unsurprisingly, there was little for social care in the Autumn Budget. But as we enter the new year and look forward to the report of the Casey Commission, care leaders are increasingly worried about funding to plug the gap before any of the commission’s reform blueprint is implemented – and to pay for change when it is.
For Caroline Abrahams, Charity Director at Age UK, the Budget was concerning not because it was silent on social care, but because of the ‘anaemic’ economic outlook it projected. ‘We’ve got a big job to do together to keep the imperative of social care reform high on the political agenda in the months and years to come,’ she says.
Sustained media coverage will be critical to meeting this challenge. For all Andy Burnham’s undoubted commitment to creating a National Care Service ‘on NHS principles’, and Baroness Casey’s mission to flesh out that vision, the reality is that the plan will be in stiff competition for scarce resources. Assuming it is a key plank of Labour’s manifesto at the next general election, voters will need convincing of the case for raising taxes.
It is, to say the least, deeply unfortunate that at just this point, the BBC has decided to do away with the dedicated role of Social Affairs Editor. Alison Holt, who has held the post since 2021, has been a staunch but critical friend of social care.
The BBC, seeking savings ahead of renegotiating its charter, says the decision to merge her role with that of Education Editor reflects ‘levels of audience interest and editorial demand’. It is similarly merging the roles of Health Editor and Medical Editor, a move that has sparked protests in NHS circles. But with all respect to our health colleagues, the NHS makes its own news.
Social care is different. It struggles for attention and has never been good at telling its story. Why? Firstly, the sector is notoriously fragmented. With 19,000 different provider organisations in England alone, operating out of 41,000 care establishments, getting everyone to sing from the same hymn sheet is challenging. Care provider associations do a good job on behalf of their members, but the lack of a single, strong voice continues to be a fatal weakness.
Secondly, there is a great reluctance to court publicity lest people who draw on care and support services are identified. This feels like a hangover from days of local authority provision of services and is, I believe, badly misguided. Many service users and their families are happy to co-operate with media coverage, if properly consulted, and some of the best exposure for the sector – think of the Ed Balls documentaries at St Cecilia’s Care Group in Scarborough – has come this way.
Thirdly, and here I put on my tin hat, the sector has for too long gone along with British society’s instinctive aversion to thinking about social care until the point of personal or family crisis. Winning the argument for a National Care Service must involve everyone facing up to the reality of our inevitable frailty, whenever that might strike. Let us all grow up about this.
As Abrahams says, there are hard yards ahead and there is a battle of political and public opinion still to be won. We need to court and to use the media in all their modern manifestations, from the BBC to TikTok influencers, and we need to get on the front foot now.
David Brindle is a social care commentator and former Public Services Editor of The Guardian. Email: [email protected] Linkedin: @David-Brindle
