post image

What’s next for the regulator? Forging an improved path

Nadra Ahmed CBE, Executive Co-Chairman at the National Care Association (NCA), delves into the findings of recent reports into the Care Quality Commission (CQC) and, drawing on NCA members’ experiences, outlines what the regulator’s priorities should be to improve its effectiveness.

It has been a tumultuous year for the regulator; the landscape of CQC changes almost daily as it actions its ‘recovery plan’. The regulator’s challenges have grown increasingly worse over time, as have providers’ frustrations. The CQC’s services have declined to the point where it is not only negative but, in many cases, destructive.

For providers, who are not only major funders of CQC through its registration process but are also at the receiving end of its approach to inspections, the organisation’s position feels untenable. If we consider the views of Dr Penny Dash and Professor Sir Mike Richards, by their own standards, CQC’s operations would fare not only as ‘Inadequate’, but the service would be under pressure to cease trading.

False promises

For some time now, we have heard unreserved apologies and promises of improvement, but there have been no tangible signs in reality. CQC’s way of working has been in decline for providers as inspections became ever more remote and increasingly data reliant. We are now being told this will change, and inspectors will return to a more visible methodology. This is where we must be – inspections must be carried out by people who understand the parameters of the service they are inspecting.

In January, we wrote to CQC having received an inordinate number of comments from NCA members who were deeply concerned about the regulator’s direction of travel. There were cases of unnecessary pressure and in others, a complete lack of empathy from inspection teams. It was clear, if providers had the option, they would switch regulators, but despite funding its very existence, the provider has no control over this critical service.

Wellbeing at risk

We received evidence from registered managers, who decided to leave the sector post-inspection because of the lack of respect for them as professionals by the inspector, who had little or no understanding of the specialist services they provided. The inspections appeared to be creating an atmosphere of pressure and staff were often left demoralised, disenfranchised and deflated.

We became increasingly concerned about the impact of a poor inspection on the mental health of our workforce and in some cases, the lack of respect for the professionals who were delivering the service. In our letter to the CQC, we challenged behaviours to prevent a culture akin to that uncovered at Ofsted, which tragically resulted in a headteacher taking her own life. The purpose of our unprecedented intervention was to prevent an escalation of the new methodology, under the ‘new ways of working’ being rolled out by the management of CQC without due consideration to the impact on those on the receiving end. This was a system which was flawed from the outset and remained inconsistent and subjective.

Change of direction

Our letter resonated with providers and other representative bodies, and we saw a steady trickle of similar correspondence from across the sector, which eventually led to CQC’s admission that there needed to be a review of their systems, which included the disastrous introduction of a portal and growing confusion over the single assessment framework (SAF). Both of these created further frustrations for providers. Despite assurances and apologies, it was becoming obvious that something had to change, and that change started with the resignation of the Chief Executive Officer.

Thus followed the announcements of the ‘Dash Review’, which was to consider the CQC’s effectiveness, closely followed by the ‘Richards Review’, which was to focus on the SAF. By this time, providers were struggling with their regulatory responsibility to upload information to a portal which was not fit for purpose and engaging with CQC was nigh on impossible for providers. All queries went through a single email address, so responses were variable, to be generous.

Failings exposed

Having worked in the sector for over 40 years, I have always advocated for an independent inspectorate and firmly believe it is in the public interest. What we saw unfolding from 2023, with the introduction of the SAF, was a system which was chaotic, obscure and totally unpredictable for providers. We also started to sense a frustration from CQC inspectors who were also being put under pressure by systems that did not do what was promised.

The Dash Review exposed major inadequacies in the way that CQC had been operating. This led to an unreserved apology from the Interim Chief Executive Officer, with the promise of change and improvement. The mantra from CQC was that it was working hard to get it right, but it did not feel like it on the ground from what NCA members were reporting.

It was becoming increasingly obvious that the recovery plan was not working. The validity of inspections was under direct scrutiny, especially for those who had not received responses to their factually accuracy or had not had an inspection for some time. We had member with new builds waiting for registrations to operate for months whilst admissions waiting lists grew.

What is baffling is that despite clear messages from both the Dash Review and the Richards Review, I have no real understanding as to how this was being allowed to happen. These decisions were taken at the highest level of the management at CQC, and it was also ratified by its Board. How can that same Board be trusted to deliver a recovery plan?

Road to recovery

The recovery plan is aspirational but not visionary. When failure is so deep set and driven by a model which was not fully thought through, but funded without limits, one wonders how that transition will happen and when? What are the time scales for the organisation’s stability? Providers are reliant on CQC for external accreditation which will impact on their ability to borrow, innovate or enter local authority contracts.

What we need is a carefully thought-out plan which will enable providers to start rebuilding public trust in CQC ratings. Providers pride themselves in the services they deliver, and they need a regulator that will ensure its assessments are fair, accurate and measure improvements in a timely fashion.

In addition, we must ensure that the findings from both reviews are used to create timelines for improvement, which include the simplification of the SAF to reflect the sector it is being used for. We must move away from generic statements and actions, as we all work differently in every part of the sector. As such, our varying outcomes must be measured accordingly to provide accurate public information.

It is inconceivable that inspections have not been scheduled in a way that ensures there is updated information available on each service in the public domain. This would provide a reliable benchmarking function which could drive up standards and support providers to have improvement plans recognised. Moreover, we must see reports issued within a time-period which will mitigate staff anxiety, which is heightened pre- and post-inspection. CQC must abide by the same deadlines it places on providers.

Re-building relationships

I believe that if the SAF remains, it must be simplified, and the quality statements reviewed to prevent duplication. Furthermore, there must be clarity on how the quality statements are answered and clear guidance on what a ‘Good’ service looks like. This will aid the inconsistencies that subjectivity brings. Subjectivity needs to be replaced with objective and impartial thinking which reflects not only ‘what we see on the day’ but acknowledges the quality of the service overall, based on feedback for those who work with and are recipients of care and support.

Relationship management with every registered service provider is also key to the CQC’s recovery. Providers must have the opportunity to mitigate against incorrect assumptions, enabling sensible conversation which would negate the need for expensive legal interventions on both sides. As a simple example, specialist services deserve specialists to inspect them, not generalists. Without this, assumptions can be made by inspection teams which can cause unnecessary challenges. It is imperative that the incoming Chief Executive Officer creates a methodology to re-build relationships with providers and those who rely on the CQC to credibly analyse the services it inspects.

A strong, fair inspectorate is what we need and deserve. Acknowledging failures is only the first step, the action taken to remedy them is what will demonstrate if the recovery plan has been well thought through. Good practice within CQC must be built upon and poor practice must be called out. The regulator cannot ignore the root causes of its failures as that will mean all the pain providers have experienced will have been in vain. After all, that is what the CQC expects from providers, so it must do the same.


What lessons can the CQC learn from the Dash Review and Richards Review? Leave a comment on this feature or join the conversation to share your thoughts.

Nadra Ahmed CBE is Executive Co-Chairman at the National Care Association (NCA).

Email: [email protected]

X: @NationalCareAsc

About Nadra Ahmed CBE

Nadra has been involved in the field of Social Care for over 40 years.

She was elected Chairman of NCA in 2001, a position now shared with Ian Turner following the recent merger with RNHA. Nadra is a trustee of Royal British Legion Industries and Governor at Canterbury Christchurch University. She is one of the Co-Convenors of the Cavendish Coalition, formed pre-Brexit, with the NHS and Unison, to support workforce issues in Health and Social Care. Nadra is the current Chair of the Care Provider Alliance.

She continues to serve on Government Taskforces and advisory committees in the DHSC, Home Office and other government departments.

Nadra holds numerous positions within voluntary organisations delivering services to vulnerable people in the community. Her passion to support social care provision is acknowledged nationally and internationally.

In 2023 Nadra was awarded the CBE for her continued services to Social Care.

Related Content

The polls are in: How to reform regulation

Inside CQC

Inside CQC

Completing the care picture: What providers may miss when residents are alone

Improving sector unity: How registered managers are contributing to nursing education

Resource Finder: Legal

Homecare Headlines

How must the Care Quality Commission (CQC) respond to the findings of Dr Dash’s interim report?

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted