My application for a digital fellowship has enabled me to tackle the question of how we use digital and artificial intelligence (AI) to enhance care.
Literature review
Initially, I looked at the evidence to find out what and how digital and AI is used in care home settings. I found most of the 110 articles had only been published in the last five years, and few were from the UK. Of the 21 articles that met the search criteria, I discovered distinct groups of digital and AI technologies that had been tested in care home settings.
These included environmental sensors, wearables, combined digital technologies, social and assistive robots and healthcare data analytics. I also considered some of the ethical issues reported.
Environment sensors
These include ‘smart’ phones, tablets and speakers, which are used to communicate with loved ones via text, Facetime, WhatsApp and other forms of video conferencing, many of which came into their own during the COVID-19 pandemic. These are also used to play music and audiobooks, to access news and weather reports, or to play games (1,2).
Sensors attached to residents’ clothing are used to monitor walking episodes from other types of activity for people with dementia (3), while bed and chair sensors with machine learning or air tags with GPS tracking are reported to prevent wandering (4) or to identify risk in the prevention of pressure ulcers (5). These sensors have also been used to provide real-time in-bed/off-bed status, providing daily records of residents’ sleep quality, prolonged pressure and living patterns.
An AI-Toilet was tested in care homes, monitoring urine and faecal outputs (6), and one trial looked at the design of futuristic incontinence wear, using sensors to detect saturation and defaecation (7).
Wearables
Evidence suggests that wearables can help monitor posture or activity and support early identification of changes in health or mood. Wearables come in different forms, such as smart watches, chest straps, hearing aids, glasses, clothes, shoes, helmets, rings and lenses.
They track activity and location, monitor vital signs and detect falls and stress, hydration, seizures, sleep and arrythmias (8). One reported wearable was a smart belt offering automatic airbag deployment, reducing the impact forces to the hip region in serious hip-impact fall scenarios (9). Improved communication between residents and staff reduced delays in staff response through smart-watch communication instead of nurse call systems (10).
Combined digital technologies
When wearables, sensors and/or apps are combined to exchange data over the internet, they are sometimes known as the ‘internet of things’ (IoT). Several combined digital technologies were evidenced in this review, including ‘Swallowscope’ (11) to detect swallowing difficulties and provide remote visual assessment by speech and language experts.
PainChek (12) is another example, providing a point-of-care medical application to assess pain in people with dementia by detecting facial expressions on a smart device connected to software that can recognise levels of pain. Telemedicine, sometimes combined with electronic stethoscopes and otoscopes, can reduce the need for hospital attendance or admission and can also enable remote prescribing (13,1).
Virtual reality was reported to enhance residents’ social engagement (14), enabling residents to virtually leave the home and reconnect with their personal interests, providing entertainment and distraction. An AI-enabled smart phone app (15) has been developed and evaluated for real-time pressure ulcer assessment, supporting care home nurses who may not have tissue viability expertise to make more accurate assessments. ‘Mindful Garden’(16 a/b), a digital screen-mounted garden display of layered motion pictures, helped manage behavioural and psychological symptoms of dementia and reduced bathing time in care homes.
Social and assistive robots
Paro the seal is reported in several papers; it is suggested that this robotic seal calms and soothes residents. Pet robots provide companionship, comfort, entertainment, wellbeing, improved mood and sleep quality, reducing occupational disruptiveness, distress and anxiety and even inducing a sense of being in a close relationship (17,18,19,20).
An assistive service robot named SMOOTH (21) has been evaluated for its ability to undertake three separate functions: transporting laundry; guiding residents to follow it; and offering beverages. Further refinement is needed, as each task required staff to input programme changes into the robot’s functions.
Healthcare data analytics
Digital care records are now in place in most care homes within England. They record health and care data, medications administered and may connect to the IoT. These digital records enable healthcare professionals to share important data with other healthcare team members and families; with AI, they can enable us to search, develop, test and learn to predict patterns in residents’ health and behaviour.
Text-mining (22) to evaluate the quality of care from narratives in residents’ records and using AI to survey statistical health data can reduce nursing care time. AI has also been used with administration systems to detect frailty and to predict falls (23,24).
Digital platforms have been developed for ‘shared care,’ co-ordination and care planning for the frail elderly, providing a set of tools centred around an electronic healthcare record (24). Alongside this, AI algorithms have been used to prevent and predict pain and subsequent agitation (25), support decision making for residents’ care in relation to pressure ulcer management26 and detect patterns of change in behaviour of residents, enabling nurses to investigate and intervene if needed (27).
Ethical considerations, barriers and enablers
Acceptability by residents and staff is an important ethical consideration in choosing and deploying digital and AI. The potential for deceit and de-humanisation were reported, particularly if automating certain nurse functions (20,28). Residents were more likely to accept the use of digital if family and staff were able to explain the benefits29. Comfort is also important in terms of acceptability for wearables and sensors (1).
Not surprisingly, consent, privacy and safety were also viewed as important ethical principles. For residents experiencing fluctuating capacity, whether they remembered they were being monitored was considered an issue of psychological safety for them (24). Staff perceptions of being monitored were also raised.
The support and training of staff, how easy learning to use digital is and ensuring there is enough IT infrastructure and support, were deemed significant for the successful use of digital and AI. Insufficient resources, staffing, inappropriate devices or apps, ‘sociotechnical ageism’ (29), limited organisational support and lack of support from families were reported as barriers which impact on the use of digital/AI in care homes.
Some practical issues were raised in this review, such as ensuring sufficient battery power, energy and internet connectivity to run smart devices and servers. Interesting solutions were proposed, including self-sustaining or energy harvesting from human movements over different flooring types and textiles (30).
Discussion
There are multiple types of digital and AI that have been developed to monitor residents’ wellbeing or support staff, prevent harm to residents, diagnose and predict patterns or behaviours, provide enrichment to the quality of residents’ lives, reduce distress, aid comfort or help with communication and interactions.
However, this literature review found that there is little research on the effectiveness and acceptability of digital or AI deployed in care homes, except around the use of certain pet robots, suggesting this is evolving technology with minimal long-term deployment in nursing homes. There is a need for longitudinal studies to evaluate the impact on residents’ quality of life and staff’s working lives.
The rhetoric that digital can release more time for the workforce to care needs to be carefully considered with each solution developed. Ease of use with minimal maintenance and little need for guidance will be imperative for new digital/AI technologies deployed in nursing homes. Additionally, staff will need training to gain skills and competencies in understanding and using digital/AI; they will be more likely to accept digital if involved in its design and deployment, supported by the organisation and its culture.
Co-designing with people with experience
Through the digital fellowship, I held a series of workshops with people living with dementia or motor neurone disease, their families and experienced care home workers, to co-design a digital decision-making tool we could use for the nursing home. We established important considerations for digital use in care homes. We turned these important aspects into questions to create a tool for care home managers and others to use in deciding what, if any, digital or AI to use in a care home. The digital decision-making tool will be further tested with other care homes for its use and applicability.
Supporting healthcare and care workers and technical experts to work together to develop robust digital solutions will help to remove perceived barriers and ensure users are included and protected (24). I would argue engaging residents and future residents of care homes and their families in the choice of digital is also important for acceptability. We disproved the myth that older people living with dementia and their families would not want to use digital or AI.
Moving forward, safe digital and AI solutions benefitting residents and staff that have been evaluated in ‘live’ care home settings will be important for our future trust and confidence in deploying digital. Finally, care home staff are close to residents and are best placed to see the potential for developing digital and AI to benefit those they care for. Harnessing this knowledge and working with AI developers directly to design solutions that will be useful is the way forward in this evolving digital world.
I’d like to acknowledge the people with experience involved in the co-design workshops and Dr Alison Warren, Associate Professor of Occupational Therapy at University of Plymouth, for their support.
Are you embracing digital and AI in your care setting? Leave a comment on this article or join the conversation to share your thoughts.
Dr Gillian Horne is Programme Director – Care Services at Rowcroft Hospice.
Email: [email protected] X: @RowcroftHospice
References
1) ZHAO, Y., ROKHANI, F.Z., SAZLINA, S., DEVARAJ, N.K., SU, J. and CHEW, B., 2022. Defining the concepts of a smart nursing home and its potential technology utilities that integrate medical services and are acceptable to stakeholders: a scoping review. BMC Geriatrics, 22(1), pp. 787.
2) HAMBLIN, K.A., 2022. Technology in care systems: Displacing, reshaping, reinstating or degrading roles? New Technology Work & Employment, 37(1), pp. 41-58.
3) PEIMANKAR, A., WINTHER, T.S., EBRAHIMI, A. and WIIL, U.K., 2023. A Machine Learning Approach for Walking Classification in Elderly People with Gait Disorders. Sensors, 23(2)
4) CHEUNG, J.C., TAM, E.W., MAK, A.H., CHAN, T.T. and ZHENG, Y., 2022. A Night-Time Monitoring System (eNightLog) to Prevent Elderly Wandering in Hostels: A Three-Month Field Study. International Journal of Environmental Research & Public Health [Electronic Resource], 19(4), pp. 02
5) DWEEKAT, O.Y., LAM, S.S. and MCGRATH, L., 2023. Machine Learning Techniques, Applications, and Potential Future Opportunities in Pressure Injuries (Bedsores) Management: A Systematic Review. International Journal of Environmental Research & Public Health [Electronic Resource], 20(1), pp. 01 01.
6) Zhang, Z.; Shi, Q.; He, T.; Guo, X.; Dong, B.; Lee, J.; Lee, C. Artificial Intelligence of Toilet (AI-Toilet) for an Integrated Health Monitoring System (IHMS) Using Smart Triboelectric Pressure Sensors and Image Sensor. Nano Energy 2021, 90 (PA), 106517.
7) RAEPSAET, C., SERRAES, B., VERHAEGHE, S. and BEECKMAN, D., 2021. Integrating Sensor Technology in Disposable Body-Worn Absorbent Products: A Qualitative Study to Define User Profile, (Technical) Criteria, Conditions, and Potential Benefits. Journal of Wound, Ostomy, & Continence Nursing, 48(6), pp. 560-567.
8) SABRY, F., ELTARAS, T., LABDA, W., ALZOUBI, K. and MALLUHI, Q., 2022. Machine Learning for Healthcare Wearable Devices: The Big Picture. Journal of Healthcare Engineering, 2022, pp. 4653923.
9) TARBERT, R.J. and SINGHATAT, W., 2023. Real World Evidence of Wearable Smartbelt for Mitigation of Fall Impact in Older Adult Care. IEEE Journal of Translational Engineering in Health and Medicine, 11, pp. 247-251.
10) ALI, H. and LI, H., 2019. Evaluating a smartwatch notification system in a simulated nursing home. International Journal of Older People Nursing, 14(3), pp. e12241.
11) KURAMOTO, N., JAYATILAKE, D., HIDAKA, K. and SUZUKI, K., 2016. Smartphone-based swallowing monitoring and feedback device for mealtime assistance in nursing homes. Annual International Conference of The IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, 2016, pp. 5781-5784.
12) ATEE, M., HOTI, K., CHIVERS, P. and HUGHES, J.D., 2022. Faces of Pain in Dementia: Learnings From a Real-World Study Using a Technology-Enabled Pain Assessment Tool. Frontiers in Pain Research, 3, pp. 827551.
13) ZULFIQAR, A., LORENZO-VILLALBA, N., ZULFIQAR, O., HAJJAM, M., COURBON, Q., ESTEOULLE, L., GENY, B., TALHA, S., LETOURNEAU, D., HAJJAM, J., ERVE, S., HAJJAM EL HASSANI, A. and ANDRES, E., 2020. e-Health: A Future Solution for Optimized Management of Elderly Patients. GER-e-TEC TM Project. Medicines, 7(8)
14) WAYCOTT, J., ZHAO, W., KELLY, R.M. and ROBERTSON, E., 2022. Technology-Mediated Enrichment in Aged Care: Survey and Interview Study. 24058297, 5(2), pp. e31162; Ar 12.
15) LAU, C.H., YU, K.H., YIP, T.F., LUK, L.Y.F., WAI, A.K.C., SIT, T., WONG, J.Y. and HO, J.W.K., 2022. An artificial intelligence-enabled smartphone app for real-time pressure injury assessment. Frontiers in Medical Technology, 4, pp. 905074.
16 a) GUTMAN, G., KARBAKHSH, M., VASHISHT, A., KAUR, T., CHURCHILL, R. and MOZTARZADEH, A., 2021. Feasibility study of a digital screen-based calming device (MindfulGarden) for bathing-related agitation among LTC residents with dementia. Gerontechnology, 20(2), pp. 1-8.
16 b) GUTMAN, G., VASHISHT, A., KAUR, T., KARBAKHSH, M., CHURCHILL, R. and MOZTARZADEH, A., 2021a. A Novel Intervention for Management of Behavioral and Psychological Symptoms of Dementia in Nursing Home Communal Areas: Results of a Small-Scale Pilot Trial. JAD Reports, 5(1), pp. 847-853.
17) BRADWELL, H., EDWARDS, K.J., WINNINGTON, R., THILL, S., ALLGAR, V. and JONES, R.B., 2022. Implementing Affordable Socially Assistive Pet Robots in Care Homes Before and During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Stratified Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial and Mixed Methods Study. 24058297, 5(3), pp. e38864; Aug 24.
18) KOH, W.Q., TOOMEY, E., FLYNN, A. and CASEY, D., 2022. Determinants of implementing of pet robots in nursing homes for dementia care. BMC Geriatrics, 22(1), pp. 457.
19) VALENTI SOLER, M., AGUERA-ORTIZ, L., OLAZARAN RODRIGUEZ, J., MENDOZA REBOLLEDO, C., PEREZ MUNOZ, A., RODRIGUEZ PEREZ, I., OSA RUIZ, E., BARRIOS SANCHEZ, A., HERRERO CANO, V., CARRASCO CHILLON, L., FELIPE RUIZ, S., LOPEZ ALVAREZ, J., LEON SALAS, B., CANAS PLAZA, J.M., MARTIN RICO, F., ABELLA DAGO, G. and MARTINEZ MARTIN, P., 2015. Social robots in advanced dementia. Frontiers in aging neuroscience, 7, pp. 133.
20) PORTACOLONE, E., HALPERN, J., LUXENBERG, J., HARRISON, K.L. and COVINSKY, K.E., 2020. Ethical Issues Raised by the Introduction of Artificial Companions to Older Adults with Cognitive Impairment: A Call for Interdisciplinary Collaborations. Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease, 76(2), pp. 445-455.
21) KRUGER, N., FISCHER, K., MANOONPONG, P., PALINKO, O., BODENHAGEN, L., BAUMANN, T., KJAERUM, J., RANO, I., NAIK, L., JUEL, W.K., HAARSLEV, F., IGNASOV, J., MARCHETTI, E., LANGEDIJK, R.M., KOLLAKIDOU, A., JEPPESEN, K.C., HEIDTMANN, C. and DALGAARD, L., 2021. The SMOOTH-Robot: A Modular, Interactive Service Robot. Frontiers in Robotics & AI, 8, pp. 645639.
22) HACKING, C., VERBEEK, H., HAMERS, J.P.H., SION, K. and AARTS, S., 2022. Text mining in long-term care: Exploring the usefulness of artificial intelligence in a nursing home setting. PLoS ONE [Electronic Resource], 17(8), pp. e0268281.
23) AMBAGTSHEER, R.C., SHAFIABADY, N., DENT, E., SEIBOTH, C. and BEILBY, J., 2020. The application of artificial intelligence (AI) techniques to identify frailty within a residential aged care administrative data set. International journal of medical informatics, 136, pp. 104094.
24) KOUROUBALI, A., KONDYLAKIS, H., LOGOTHETIDIS, F. and KATEHAKIS, D.G., 2022. Developing an AI Enabled Integrated Care Platform for Frailty. Healthcare, 10(3)
25) HUSEBO, B.S., VISLAPUU, M., CYNDECKA, M.A., MUSTAFA, M. and PATRASCU, M., 2022. Understanding Pain and Agitation Through System Analysis Algorithms in People With Dementia. A Novel Explorative Approach by the DIGI.PAIN Study. Frontiers in Pain Research, 3, pp. 847578.
26) LEE, S., SHIN, J.H., AHN, J., LEE, J.Y. and JANG, D.E., 2021. Identifying the Risk Factors Associated with Nursing Home Residents’ Pressure Ulcers Using Machine Learning Methods. International Journal of Environmental Research & Public Health [Electronic Resource], 18(6), pp. 03
27) BAI, D., HO, M., MATHUNJWA, B.M. and HSU, Y., 2023. Deriving Multiple-Layer Information from a Motion-Sensing Mattress for Precision Care. Sensors, 23(3),
29) NEVES, B.B., PETERSEN, A., VERED, M., CARTER, A. and OMORI, M., 2023. Artificial Intelligence in LongTerm Care: Technological Promise, Aging Anxieties, and Sociotechnical Ageism. Journal of Applied Gerontology, 42(6), pp. 1274-1282.
28) COCO, K., KANGASNIEMI, M. and RANTANEN, T., 2018. Care Personnel’s Attitudes and Fears Toward Care Robots in Elderly Care: A Comparison of Data from the Care Personnel in Finland and Japan. Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 50(6), pp. 634-644
29) GRIMME, S.A., KOLLAKIDOU, A., SONDERSKOV ZARP, C., HORNECKER, E., KRUGER, N., GRAF, P. and MARCHETTI, E., 2023. Floor Cleaners as Helper Pets: Projecting Assistive Robots’ Agency on Zoomorphic Affordances. Sn Computer Science, 4(4), pp. 372.
30) SHI, Q., YANG, Y., SUN, Z. and LEE, C., 2022. Progress of Advanced Devices and Internet of Things Systems as Enabling Technologies for Smart Homes and Health Care. ACS Materials Au, 2(4), pp. 394- 435.