The Prime Minister is right to put social care at the heart of his programme, and right that a National Care Service should be free at the point of use, fully funded and start in the home. We have long supported pooling the financial risk of care. Nobody should lose their home or savings because of the illness they develop.
Removing charges would bring real gains. It would ease pressure on disabled people whose benefits pay for their support, remove a charging boundary that can delay hospital discharge and encourage people to seek help earlier, when it can do most good.
But ‘free’ describes what the citizen pays, not what the state buys. Unless we change how care is commissioned and funded, we risk transferring the bill into a system already purchasing care below its cost.
In England, employing a homecare worker lawfully at the National Living Wage costs £26.17 per hour in 2026/27, before the other costs of running a safe service. Our Minimum Price for Homecare is £34.42 per hour. Training, supervision, scheduling, technology and regulatory compliance cannot be wished away.
Places already providing free personal care show why this matters. Hammersmith & Fulham, the only council in England to offer free homecare, pays some providers £19.29 per hour, almost £11 short of the £30.18 needed to employ a care worker lawfully at the London Living Wage.
Northern Ireland’s regional tariff of £22.13 per hour is below the direct cost of employment, and it has the UK’s highest proportion of 15-minute visits. These examples do not undermine the principle of free care. They show what happens when the charge is removed but delivery is under-funded: rationed minutes, insecure work and unmet need.
Nor will changing ownership fix the arithmetic. The Prime Minister said care should be about people, not profit. We agree. But £19.29 per hour does not cover the cost of care, whoever provides it. The right test is how an organisation behaves, not who owns it.
Government must also plan for what happens when charges disappear. Councils lose charging income. People who previously went without may come forward. Providers may lose the higher fees paid by people funding their own care, which prop up inadequate public rates. Unless funding matches all three pressures, the gap will be closed through tighter eligibility, longer waits or shorter visits.
Reform should begin with what people need to live fulfilling lives. A nationally consistent assessment should create a portable entitlement, with people choosing support from a quality-assured local network. Need sets the budget, the person directs it and the provider has flexibility over delivery. Outcomes, experience and quality tell us whether it works.
That means moving beyond retrospective payment for contact minutes. Providers need funding for assessed need and planned capacity, so they can organise reliable services and pay careworkers for the whole working round, including travel. Helping someone regain their independence should not cost a provider income.
None of this should wait for the next Parliament. Three foundations can be laid now: a national price floor, below which no council or NHS body can buy care; a fully funded Fair Pay Agreement, so providers can deliver better pay and conditions; and a national contract setting clear standards on quality, workforce and continuity, with the funding to meet them.
Free personal care could be a profound reform. But a promise made to the public must not be paid for by care workers, or by people whose visits are cut short. Free at the point of use must also mean fair at the point of delivery.
Dr Jane Townson OBE is Chief Executive Officer at the Homecare Association. Email: [email protected] Linkedin: @Homecare-Association
