Dementia is life changing, but a diagnosis is not, contrary to some accounts, life ending. Yes, the disease can, over time, rob people of memory, self-identity and agency and transform relationships. But how society responds to people living with dementia need not and should not deepen and accelerate that loss.
Indeed, as a society we can scaffold and strengthen the ability of people and families to live as well as possible with dementia. We can do so by helping people stay connected and active, maintain purpose and a sense of self, and by walking alongside people and families before pressures build and boil over into crisis.
Yet, while our health system is striving to diagnose dementia ever earlier, our system of care and support is reaching people later. As a result, people and families struggle to secure a diagnosis, an experience that can be traumatising, and then too often describe feeling as though they have been dropped off a cliff.
A desert of social and emotional support leaves many to cope alone, isolated and under growing pressure. People turn to their GP surgery, which can do little to help, or call 999. An emergency hospital admission can make matters worse, particularly when people cannot be discharged home in a timely way. Families avoid adult social care, assuming their only option is a care home admission yet can find traditional time-and-task homecare insufficient to meet needs.
Residential or nursing care ultimately becomes the only option, with families – or local government – facing huge costs:
- People with dementia visit the GP up to three times more each year than someone without dementia of the same age.
- Approximately 25% of acute hospital beds are occupied by people with dementia at any given time.
- People with dementia often stay in hospital twice as long and are more likely to be admitted for treatable infections.
- 70-80% of residents of residential and nursing care homes have dementia.
Importantly, this trajectory is not fixed. Where medicine is focused on ‘disease-modifying treatments’ to alter the trajectory of Alzheimer’s disease, we can also develop life-modifying support that alters the trajectory of how people and families are able to live with dementia. It is to those ends that the Live More test-and-learn initiative in Greater Manchester has been focused.
Asking the right questions
Live More started with some questions: what if we could reach people and families living with dementia earlier, not with an offer of ‘care’, but with a relationship focused on helping people and families to stay connected to and involved with the people, places and things that matter to them? Would people take up the offer? Would it improve their wellbeing? Might this help reduce pressures on the system and make any investment pay for itself over the long term?
At Shared Lives Plus, we came to this with a 40-year history of seeing how Shared Lives care typically supports adults with a learning disability to live the fullest of lives, with stable, consistent relationships supported by carers using their own homes in ordinary neighbourhoods and communities. Could we adapt this approach by offering it earlier to people and families living with dementia?
Making a difference
In 2025, we worked with Greater Manchester Association of Directors of Adult Social Services (ADASS), all 10 local authorities, NHS Greater Manchester, the Greater Manchester Combined Authority and local people living with dementia and their families to design and test Live More – Shared Lives day arrangements as a model of early action. A logic model, aligned with the existing aims of Greater Manchester’s Live Well Dementia strategy, gave the work further focus.
With the help of Andy Burnham, then Mayor of Greater Manchester, Shared Lives schemes developed new relationships with local voluntary, community and health partners, who helped to identify people living with dementia who were invited to take part. They were carefully matched with approved Shared Lives carers and spent time together weekly.
During an initial six months, 140 people and families tried out Live More, with 69 people with dementia enjoying 670 weekly sessions with matched Shared Lives carers. For Maxine, the difference could be seen when her husband John came home after spending time with Shared Lives carer, Ged. John, who is living with Alzheimer’s, rediscovered his enjoyment of walking and being outdoors and came to see Ged as a friend. Maxine said he would return home ‘full of enthusiasm’.
Those few hours mattered to Maxine too. Caring for John alongside her 95-year-old mum, who also lives with dementia, she described being able to relax knowing John was with someone she trusted. Their experience, and those of other people, families and Shared Lives carers documented in the Live More film, illustrate that support for the person living with dementia and support for their family are not separate.
Striking and measurable outcomes
An independent evaluation of the initiative has found that the support led to outcomes including:
- Improved mood and wellbeing.
- Re-engagement with activities that give life meaning and sustain identity.
- Greater choice, autonomy and dignity.
- Psychological respite and greater resilience for family carers.
- Support to remain at home for longer.
- Filling gaps around formal provision.
What is striking is that the value comes from the relationship itself: careful matching, consistency and support built around who somebody is and what matters to them. That relationship benefits the person living with dementia but also creates confidence and breathing space for their family.
Meanwhile, an independent Social Return on Investment analysis found measurable economic value associated with Live More, particularly through improvements in the wellbeing of people living with dementia and their families, amounting to around £6 of social value for every £1 invested.
The evaluation concluded that the key characteristics of the approach that were instrumental to achieving this were:
- Relationships experienced as friendship, not care.
- Careful, deliberate matching based on shared interests, passions and personalities.
- Consistency of relationship over time, rather than constantly changing care staff.
- Person-led, flexible support focused on people being and doing the things that matter to them.
- Deliberately framing the offer around connection, shared interests and values, rather than ‘care’.
- Conversations, rather than assessments, to build trust and confidence.
These outcomes strongly align with the goals of the NHS 10 Year Plan, the pursuit of Neighbourhood Health and Government’s goal of a more preventative social care system.
They are also aligned with the aim of the Modern Service Framework for Frailty and Dementia, which the Chief Social Worker for England, Sarah McClinton, who co-chairs the group developing the framework, has described as ‘a great opportunity to be ambitious about what is most important to people and how services should best support people living with dementia and/or frailty, and their carers, to live fulfilling lives.’
That ambition is particularly relevant to Live More, a model that supported people to remain part of ordinary community life while giving families trusted support around them. In that sense, Live More offers practical learning about what Government’s ambition could look like beyond clinical care.
A funding gap
Live More in Greater Manchester was made possible by the Department of Health and Social Care’s Accelerating Reform Fund. Unfortunately, few local councils have the scope to support test-and-learn initiatives, or to fund evaluation, let alone ones that reach people with dementia who may not yet have ‘eligible needs’. Budgets allocated to support for family carers are minimal.
Meanwhile, methodologies for evaluating social interventions are under-developed and costly, making it hard for non-clinical interventions like Live More to gain traction in an environment where clinical outcomes are often subject to extensive trials and cost-benefit analysis. The same applies where local council commissioners want evidence that any investment will help deliver immediate savings, rather than achieve a better long-term use of public resources.
That is why, with partners including the Local Government Association, Association of Directors of Adult Social Services, #SocialCareFuture, Mencap and others, Shared Lives Plus has called on Government to create an early action innovation fund.
A growing body of evidence
In her position as Chair of the Independent Commission on Adult Social Care, Baroness Louise Casey has called for ‘greater clinical ambition’ around finding treatments and, ultimately, a cure for dementia. Everyone should want this, but the truth is that meaningful treatments remain many years away.
In the meantime, there is a growing body of evidence about the feasibility, transformative value and impact of relational social innovations that reach people early. We can begin to irrigate that desert, helping to ensure people and families do not go on this journey alone and supporting them to live better with dementia. Clinical ambition must be matched by social ambition for the lives and wellbeing of people living with dementia today.
Find out more about the Live More programme here. Then share your thoughts on this feature by leaving a comment below.
Suzi Clark is Head of Strategic Advice and Development at Shared Lives Plus. Email: [email protected] Linkedin: @Suzi-Clark.
Neil Crowther is an independent social change consultant. Email: [email protected] Linkedin: @Neil-Crowther
